I wanted to get my thoughts on Urban Decay's shadow pencils up before the end of
the giveaway (extended through Memorial Day! Go enter if you haven't!), but didn't feel like doing a full review and happened to have swatches of Hourglass Gypsy that I needed to do something with, so...here's a quick combo review!
 |
Juju (left), Sin (right) |
Urban Decay's eyeliners are cult favorites (I have
Mildew and Rockstar, and love the former [the latter is a bit too glittertastic]), so everybody was pretty psyched when they came out with bigger shadow pencils. I picked up the 5 pack they'd released for the holidays when it was on super-sale and kept the two lighter neutrals for myself (the others are
here), and have been using them on and off for the past couple months.
 |
| Juju (top), Sin (bottom) |
Sin is a shimmery light champagne, and Juju is a shimmery taupe. They're pretty firm, so I just swipe it all over my lid and then blend to soften the edges. On their own, they crease and fade pretty badly on my oily lids, but they last ~8 hours over TFSI, and longer if I top them with powder shadow.
Sin blended all over lid, Juju blended in crease
They do need to be sharpened, but I've gotten a lot of wear out of them without needing to do so yet (the only reason I did was to test and make sure it could be sharpened before writing this review, and yes, it can––I used the larger hole in the $2 Revlon sharpener I have to no ill effects). I wouldn't pay $20 for one, but I'm very pleased to have the ones I do!
Grade: B (if you get them for cheap, A-)
$20 for 0.10 oz, available from
Sephora and
Urban Decay